The Retort

Pro-Life Side to the Women’s Decision

November 4th, 2011 by Patricia Hampton Of The Retort Staff

In a piece rebutting an abortion article, it would not be surprising to hear from the pro-life side of the conversation – in fact, that would almost be expected.

With that said, I would much rather focus on the overall validity of the argument and the truly unacceptable points made with regard to abortion being the woman’s decision.

First, I’m sure that Carillo is familiar with the well-known fact that human pregnancy without BOTH a man and a woman cannot occur. To say that “men should not even have a say on whether the woman should have an abortion or not” suggests that this fact was overlooked. The couple shares the responsibility of the pregnancy – they are equally responsible. Biologically speaking, the man has just as much claim to the child as the woman does. So no, the woman should not disregard or disrespect the wishes of the child’s father.

The most atrocious point made in the article is in reference to disabled children. What gives anyone the right to say that these children “suffer”? And what is the definition of “suffer” in this instance? Sure, these people face challenges, and depending on the circumstances, they may face discomfort or pain, but does that mean that they do not have the will to live?

I have known individuals with disabilities, and they are among the happiest people I have met, and probably the most excited and optimistic about life. I have seen the student who “suffers” from “being different from the other kid,” but this has resulted in a positive light. These are the students that are cheerful, and make everyone smile as they walk through the halls greeting everyone, who are cheered on during dance-offs at high school proms, and who receive thunderous applause for achievements and awards that they receive. They are kind people, who care about those who surround them and appreciate the lives that they live and the opportunities they have – they take little for granted.

So before condemning all unborn children doctors know will be born with disabilities to be aborted, consider this: These children are not “sick,” they are unique in their ways, they ARE human, and they deserve to live just as much as anyone else.